Write a short reflection paragraph about this peer review in comparison with the first one. Was it easier or more challenging? If you were not given guidelines, how might you complete peer review differently? Would you prefer to comment without guidelines for your final peer review?

I can’t say that the second peer review was harder or easier than the first peer review because the second peer review had different requirements than the first. I found I was paying attention to different aspects of the essay which required me to think about what we had been learning from They Say, I say. I find the guidelines helpful in completing the peer review as it makes my comments more specific thus more helpful so I would prefer to have guidelines for the final essay.